Partners considering the best lubricant

The Lubricant Guide You Need

Welcome! I'm Dr. Lori Davis, DNP, FNP-C.

I've spent years in the room with couples stuck around desire and intimacy.  Here is what I have learned.

The 6-Day Mismatched Desire Reset

Get started now

    Is mismatched desire running your relationship?

    This free 6-day reset will show you why — and what to actually do about it.

    by Dr. Lori Davis, NP, Certified Sex Counselor, Relationship Coach


    Let’s talk about something that could dramatically improve your sex life tonight—but that most people feel weirdly embarrassed to use.

    Lubricant.

    If you’re not using it, you’re missing out on better, more comfortable, more pleasurable sex. And if you are using it, you might be using the wrong kind—one that’s actually not great for your vaginal health or isn’t slippery enough to do the job right.

    Here’s what frustrates me: Lubricant should be as standard as toothpaste. Everyone should have a bottle they love. But instead, most people either don’t use it at all, or they grab whatever’s at the drugstore without knowing what they’re putting in their body.

    TL;DR

    • Lubricant should be standard, not shameful — everyone benefits from it, regardless of how much natural lubrication they produce
    • Natural lubrication is not a reliable indicator of arousal — hormones, medications, stress, and individual variation all affect it
    • The lubricant you choose matters — many common brands contain ingredients that dry out tissue or disrupt your vaginal microbiome
    • Four types to know — water-based, silicone-based, oil-based, and hybrid, each with different uses and compatibility considerations
    • Avoid these ingredients — parabens, glycerin, chlorhexidine, petroleum, and anything labeled “warming” or “arousing”
    • Moisturizers and lubricants are different things — moisturizers are for daily vaginal health, lubricants are for sex
    • You can have more than one — different lubricants for different situations is completely reasonable

    Why You Should Use Lubricant (Even If You Get Wet)

    First, let’s address the elephant in the room: Many people think using lubricant means something is wrong.

    Wrong with their body. Wrong with their arousal. Wrong with their relationship.

    This is nonsense.

    Yes, vaginal lubrication naturally occurs for many people when they’re aroused. And yes, getting wet can feel validating—a visible sign of desire, femininity, sexual vitality.

    But here’s the truth: Natural lubrication is not a reliable indicator of arousal.

    Emily Nagoski explains this concept brilliantly in Come As You Are when she discusses arousal non-concordance. Your body can respond physiologically to sexual stimuli (getting wet) without your mind being turned on. And conversely, you can be genuinely aroused and not produce much lubrication.

    Why? Because lubrication is affected by:

    • Hormone levels (especially estrogen)
    • Medications (antidepressants, antihistamines, birth control)
    • Stress and anxiety
    • Dehydration
    • Where you are in your menstrual cycle
    • Menopause
    • Just… individual variation

    Every body is unique. Some people produce lots of lubrication. Some don’t. Neither is better or worse.

    Carrying shame about not getting wet enough is like carrying shame about not producing enough saliva. It’s just how your body works—and it says nothing about your sexuality or desirability.


    The Case for Using Lubricant Every Time

    Here’s my recommendation: Use lubricant every time, whether you “need” it or not.

    Why?

    1. It increases pleasure from the very start
    Lubricant on the clitoris, vulva, and vaginal opening feels amazing. It kicks sexual pleasure into high gear immediately, rather than waiting for your body to produce enough natural lubrication.

    2. More lubrication can increase arousal
    Feeling wetness can signal to your brain that you’re aroused, which can deepen arousal. It’s a positive feedback loop.

    3. It takes pressure off your body
    When you know lubricant is part of the equation, you don’t have to worry whether you’re “wet enough.” You can focus on pleasure instead of performance.

    4. It’s essential for some activities
    Anal play requires lubricant (the anus doesn’t self-lubricate). But honestly? Lubricant makes everything better—vulvas, clitorises, penises, nipples, wherever.

    The formula is simple: Lubricant + Sexual Play = More Pleasure

    There is no shame in the lubricant game.


    Not All Lubricants Are Created Equal

    Now for the part that most people don’t know: The lubricant you choose actually matters.

    That bottle of KY Jelly or Astroglide you grabbed at the grocery store? It might be doing more harm than good.

    Many common lubricants contain ingredients that:

    • Dry out vaginal tissue
    • Disrupt the vaginal microbiome
    • Cause irritation or burning
    • Increase risk of infections
    • May even increase STI transmission risk

    I’m not trying to scare you. I’m trying to give you information so you can make good choices for your body.

    What you need: A lubricant that’s super slippery AND healthy for your vaginal tissue.


    The Four Types of Lubricant (And Which to Choose)

    Lubricants fall into four main categories. Here’s what you need to know:

    Water-Based Lubricants

    Pros:

    • Safe with condoms and all sex toys
    • Easy to clean up
    • Available in many consistencies
    • Good option: Good Clean Love

    Cons:

    • Dry out quickly
    • Need reapplication or a few drops of water/saliva to stay slippery
    • Not the slipperiest option

    Best for: Use with condoms and vibrators

    Silicone-Based Lubricants

    Pros:

    • Stay slippery much longer than water-based
    • Hypoallergenic (don’t absorb into skin, no preservatives)
    • Great for sensitive or dry skin
    • Good option: Uberlube

    Cons:

    • More expensive
    • Cannot be used with silicone sex toys
    • Can be harder to clean up

    Best for: Maximum slipperiness, skin-to-skin contact, shower sex

    Oil-Based Lubricants

    Pros:

    • Hydrate tissue
    • Last a long time
    • Natural option available (coconut oil)
    • Inexpensive
    • Good option: Unrefined coconut oil

    Cons:

    • NOT compatible with latex condoms (will break down latex)
    • Some people report increased infections (though research is mixed)
    • Can stain sheets

    Best for: Solo play, monogamous fluid-bonded couples not using condoms

    Coconut oil tip: Scoop into quarter-sized balls and freeze in a container. Makes it easy to use, avoids contamination, and the cool temperature can be soothing.

    Hybrid Lubricants

    Pros:

    • Combination of water and silicone
    • Last longer than water-based but not as long as pure silicone
    • Compatible with condoms and most sex toys
    • Good option: Sliquid

    Cons:

    • Some aren’t compatible with silicone toys
    • More expensive than water-based

    Best for: People who want longevity but need condom compatibility


    Ingredients to Avoid

    Stay away from lubricants containing:

    • Parabens
    • Glycerin
    • Chlorhexidine
    • Mineral oil
    • Petroleum
    • Propylene glycol
    • “Warming” or “arousing” ingredients (these often cause irritation)

    Why it matters: Some lubricants have pH levels or osmolality that don’t match the vaginal environment. This can dry out tissue, disrupt the microbiome, and increase risk of irritation and infection.

    The World Health Organization actually researched this because they were concerned that bad lubricants could cause tissue damage and increase STI transmission risk. They created guidelines—manufacturers just don’t always follow them.


    You Don’t Have to Choose Just One

    Here’s the good news: You can have different lubricants for different situations.

    Maybe you use:

    • Water-based for sex with condoms
    • Silicone for skin-to-skin contact when you want maximum slip
    • Coconut oil for solo play or massage

    Experiment. Find what works for your body and your situations.


    What About Vaginal Moisturizers?

    You might see moisturizers mixed in with lubricants at the store, but they’re different products with different purposes.

    Lubricants: Used as needed during sexual activity

    Moisturizers: Used routinely (3-5 times per week) for ongoing vaginal dryness, especially during menopause

    Vaginal moisturizers work like facial moisturizers—they hold water in tissue to prevent dehydration. They’re not for sex; they’re for general vulvovaginal health.

    Good moisturizer options:

    • Hyalo Gyn (contains hyaluronic acid)
    • Ah! Yes
    • Good Clean Love Moisturizing Vaginal Gel

    If you’re experiencing vaginal dryness due to menopause or low estrogen, you likely need both a moisturizer (for daily use) AND a lubricant (for sex). For more on vaginal dryness after menopause, read Why Does Sex Hurt After Menopause? For comprehensive guidance on using moisturizers and other treatments for comfortable sex after menopause, see 5 Things You Can Do to Have Pain-Free Sex After Menopause


    How to Bring Lubricant Into the Bedroom

    Maybe you’re convinced about the benefits but feel awkward actually using it during sex.

    I get it. Here’s how to make it less intimidating:

    Start with non-genital touch:

    1. Caress each other’s hands
    2. Add lotion or massage oil
    3. Notice how much better friction-reduced touch feels
    4. Try it on other body parts—arms, legs, back
    5. Realize that sexual lubricant is just the same concept, but formulated to be safe for vulvas

    Reframe it mentally:

    • Lubricant isn’t a sign of failure; it’s an enhancement
    • You wouldn’t feel weird about using toothpaste or shampoo
    • Good sex includes tools that increase pleasure

    Choose packaging that works for you:

    • Some lubricant bottles are very “sexy” looking
    • If that feels too explicit, use coconut oil in a plain container
    • Or transfer your favorite lubricant into a simple pump bottle

    The Bottom Line

    Lubricant is the original sex aid—and one of the most underutilized.

    Whether you get naturally wet or not, whether you’re having penetrative sex or just external play, whether you’re solo or partnered—lubricant makes everything better.

    Find products that work for your body. Use them without shame. And give yourself permission to prioritize your pleasure.

    Find products that work for your body. Use them without shame. Pleasure is worth the effort.


    Working With Me

    If vaginal dryness, discomfort, or pain are getting in the way of pleasure, there’s usually more going on than just needing better lubricant. I work with individuals and couples on the full picture, from the physical to the relational. In person in Ithaca or virtually anywhere in the US.

    Learn more about working together here. Book a free consultation here.


    Dr. Lori Davis is a Doctor of Nursing Practice, board-certified Family Nurse Practitioner, and AASECT Certified Sex Counselor specializing in sexual pain, vaginal health, and sexual pleasure. She teaches sexuality counseling at the University of Michigan.


    Further Reading

    When Sex Feels Like A Chore: Reclaiming Pleasure as Self-Care

    Why Does Sex Hurt After Menopause?

    Why Don’t I Want Sex Anymore: Understanding Responsive Desire

    Mismatched Desire in Relationships Explained


    Note on language: In this article, terms like “woman/women” and “vagina/vulva” refer to anatomy rather than gender identity. This information applies to anyone with this anatomy, regardless of gender.

    The 6-Day Mismatched Desire Reset

      Is mismatched desire running your relationship?

      This free 6-day reset will show you why — and what to actually do about it.

      Get started now

        Join the Newsletter

        Get monthly insights on intimacy, desire, and relationships that I don't share anywhere else. Real talk about what's actually happening in your sex life — and what to do about it.

        Stay in the know!